How did Irish attitudes change after World War One?

Part ofHistoryBritain and Ireland, 1900 - 1985

Quick version

At the 1918 General Election the republican party, Sinn Féin, won an overwhelming majority:

  • they formed an Irish parliament – the Dáil Éireann
  • they declared independence from Britain and the formation of an Irish Free State
  • they set up alternative institutions such as law courts

Irish Unionists saw this as a threat to their British identity. They wanted protection and support from the British Government.

The British Government declared the Dáil was illegal and it outlawed Sinn Féin.

But it also released all Irish political prisoners. This strengthening the movement against British rule.

Back to top

Video - Ireland, 1918 to 1921

Watch this video to learn how growing tension after World War One led to the violence of the Irish War of Independence (Anglo-Irish War) before the Anglo-Irish Treaty was reached.

Back to top

Learn in more depth

It is generally accepted that there was a significant amount of unrest against British rule before World War One. This can be seen in the widespread support for the Home Rule movement outside of North-East Ulster.

Such feelings intensified and became more radical during the war, as a result of events such as the Easter Rising and the anti-conscription campaign.

This radicalisation can be clearly seen in the 1918 General Election results that followed the war.

Back to top

Ireland and the 1918 General Election

A woman votes at the 1918 General Election.Image source, Universal History Archive / Getty
Image caption,
The first election since before World War One, the 1918 General Election returned a sizeable majority for Sinn Féin. It was an election that allowed some women and all men over 21 the right to vote.

After the end of World War One in November 1918, a General Election was held. It was the first election in the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland that allowed all men over the age of 21 to vote.

Sinn Féin, who had a more radical separatist agenda, secured 73 seats, whereas the more moderate Irish Parliamentary Party went from over 70 seats to just six.

Rather than securing a moderate Home Rule arrangement through parliamentary means, Sinn Féin advocated complete separation:

  • withdrawing from the UK Parliament in Westminster
  • establishing a constituent Irish assembly in Dublin

They also advocated using ‘any and every means available’ to remove British governance from Ireland. This included ‘military force’.

More people than ever were prepared to wage armed struggle against British rule, either by engaging in conflict themselves. or my supporting others who would.

It may be of note that the unemployment rate for demobilised servicemen in Ireland was 46%, compared to just 10% in the rest of the UK.

This could have increased resentment, and possibly even a willingness to take up arms against those who the soldiers had previously fought for.

This feeling existed not just in Ireland, but among the Irish in the USA. On a trip to the USA in 1920, Sinn Fein President Éamon de Valera was able to raise $5 million for the cause of ‘forcing the British out’.

A woman votes at the 1918 General Election.Image source, Universal History Archive / Getty
Image caption,
The first election since before World War One, the 1918 General Election returned a sizeable majority for Sinn Féin. It was an election that allowed some women and all men over 21 the right to vote.
Back to top

Role of the Dáil and the Declaration of Independence

Having won a majority in 1918 General Election, Sinn Féin established a new parliament for Ireland, the Dáil Éireann. This met at the Mansion House in Dublin. The Dáil was declared illegal by the British Government.

One of the first acts of Dáil Éireann was to issue a Declaration of Independence.

What did the Irish Declaration of Independence say?

Alternative Irish institutions

In addition to setting up a formal parliament it was decided to establish Irish alternatives to other institutions of the British state. The hope was that the British versions would ‘wither away’.

Over 1000 law courts were set up by Sinn Féin as an alternative to the traditional justice system. Often a priest or lawyer presided over these courts. Their rule was enforced by the new Irish Republican Army.

Taxes were to be diverted to the new Ministry of Finance, headed by Michael Collins. He was able to raise approximately £350,000, which supported the efforts of republicans fighting against the British in the ongoing Anglo-Irish War.

Weaknesses of the Dáil

Newspaper front page announcing the opening of the Dáil Éireann, 1919.Image source, Hulton Archive / Getty
Image caption,
An edition of the Irish Independent newspaper announcing the opening of the Dáil Éireann on 22 January, 1919.

It is possible to overestimate the strength of Dáil Éireann.

  • They failed to meet regularly, with only 21 sessions between 1919 and 1921.
  • When they did meet, many members were absent, often because they were in prison or in hiding.
  • Éamon de Valera himself was absent from Ireland between June 1919 and December 1920

The parliament lacked consistent leadership and was without the most respected and recognised Irish leader associated with it.

The Dáil failed to be recognised internationally. At the end of World War One, representatives of the Dáil were humiliated at the Versailles peace negotiations. When pleading the case for Ireland to be given national self-determination, the delegates from other nations did not recognise their legitimacy.

Although the nationalist/republican militia, the Irish Volunteers, had to take an oath to Dáil Éireann by August 1919, the Dáil had very little control over the Irish Volunteers.

Newspaper front page announcing the opening of the Dáil Éireann, 1919.Image source, Hulton Archive / Getty
Image caption,
An edition of the Irish Independent newspaper announcing the opening of the Dáil Éireann on 22 January, 1919.
Back to top

Irish Unionist attitudes after WW1

An anti Home Rule protest, Belfast, 1912.Image source, Hulton Archive / Getty
Image caption,
An anti Home Rule protest, Belfast, 1912. Ulster Protestants opposed Home Rule and any political measure that they perceived distanced them from Britain.

Attitudes of Irish Unionists also became more extreme after the World War One, particularly in Ulster.

In Ulster, Protestants made up 56% of the prewar population, but provided 73% of Irish recruits to the British war effort.

The Ulster Protestants were proud of the wartime actions of their 36th Ulster Division, and their service came to symbolise the loyalty of their community to the crown.

On the first day of the Battle of the Somme, 2,000 men of the 36th Ulster Division were killed on the first day alone. Almost half of Victoria Crosses awarded for bravery on that day were given to men of the 36th.

For many Ulster Protestants, this was seen as an argument that their ‘blood sacrifice’ ought to be rewarded by the exclusion of Ulster from Home Rule.

Of course, it was not only Ulster Protestants who fought and died for Britain: some 40,000 Irishmen of both religions did not return home.

However the Unionist community strongly believed that they, unlike the Catholic ‘rebels’ had proved themselves loyal to Britain, and expected to remain fully within the union when the war ended.

The contrast between the opposing views of unionists and nationalists were more than they had been before the war.

An anti Home Rule protest, Belfast, 1912.Image source, Hulton Archive / Getty
Image caption,
An anti Home Rule protest, Belfast, 1912. Ulster Protestants opposed Home Rule and any political measure that they perceived distanced them from Britain.
Back to top

Response of the British Government

The response of the British Government to the unfolding crisis in Ireland was initially confused and contradictory.

The Dáil was declared illegal, and both Sinn Féin and the IRA outlawed.

However in March 1919, the British Government released all Irish political prisoners. But this strengthening the movement against the British and gave their political opponents a sense of legitimacy.

The lack of consistency in British action might be because the Ireland portfolio at this time was handled by a succession of junior ministers, Irish historian Ronan Fanning has argued this is because more established political figures would not touch such a difficult challenge.

Back to top

Test your knowledge

Quiz

Back to top

Recap what you have learned

At the 1918 General Election after the end of World War One, the republican Sinn Féin party won an overwhelming majority of Irish seats:

  • they formed an Irish parliament – the Dáil Éireann
  • they declared independence from Britain and the formation of an Irish Free State
  • they set up alternative institutions such as law courts and a Ministry of Finance

Irish Unionists, many in Ulster, saw this as a threat to their British identity and wanted protection and support from the British Government.

The British Government declared the Dáil was illegal and it outlawed Sinn Féin.

But it also released all Irish political prisoners. This strengthening the movement against British rule.

Back to top