Summary

Your views

  1. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 13:57 GMT

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    United hierarchy to blame, have they appointed a top manager since Fergie left? Maybe Jose, but he wasn't backed with transfers. Look at Lindelof and AWB at Villa under Emery, reformed, that's what top coaching does.

    Mathew

  2. 'What is your expectation?'published at 13:54 GMT

    Chelsea v Manchester United (Sat, 12:30 GMT)

    Roy Keane
    Former Manchester United captain on the Stick to Football podcast

    We go back to it, are the players playing for him? Also the players are contracted to Manchester United, they are not contracted to Michael Carrick.

    Managers will come and go but if the players aren’t, when people go ‘they care’, they might care but they don’t care enough. They don’t care enough and we talk about stats and we said to people, your stats are important, particularly for goal scorers or whatever.

    When he got the job last year, Carrick went in there and people said, we said it from day one, we didn’t think he was probably good enough long term. It’s alright, we said, managing a few games.

    All of a sudden then you’ve got to manage the football club and that’s pre-season expectations, recruitment. You are involved in that and they were getting results last year, and when you got results last year, people said you’ve got to give him the job because of the results.

    Now they’re not getting the results, oh it’s the board, it’s Wilcox, it’s somebody else. It's all part of the package I get it, all of the culture, the training ground. I’d love to know what happened in pre-season but Michael Carrick, his coaches Johnny, Woodgate, Holland – they are still lucky boys to be involved at Man United, but they have to start getting results, on Saturday get a result at Chelsea.

    They kind of had it at Leeds, but we’re hearing lots of stuff coming out, players trained well last week, they're a good group, someone’s apologised, they went to Leeds and after they match, this idea that we’ve got to draw at Leeds, you’re like what is your expectation?

    But then I give him a thumbs up, yeah you dug in and got a result and then what happens in Como? They lose 4-1, it could have been six or seven against Como. Setbacks is part of sport, what you want as a manager or a player going ‘we need a reaction’, [then] they lose at home, without getting a tackle on anybody.

  3. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 13:51 GMT

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    To go from Ferguson having almost absolute power - and using that power expertly - to this shambolic group of plastic job titles trying to be more important than the rest is ridiculous. Carrick is not the issue, and that was probably true of other managers. Not Amorim though...

    Sam

  4. Carrick's pre-Bournemouth monologue failed to trigger a reactionpublished at 13:47 GMT

    Chelsea v Manchester United (Sat, 12:30GMT)

    Simon Stone
    BBC Sport Manchester United reporter

    When Michael Carrick spoke to us before Sunday's Premier League game against Bournemouth he started with a five-and-a-half minute monologue, highlighting what Manchester United means to him and what he sees as the fundamentals around the club.

    It was stirring stuff and you could tell it came from the heart.

    It was suggested he was reading a script but I was sat a few feet away and can confirm that was total nonsense.

    Sadly for Carrick, it did not translate to the pitch.

    United were beaten 3-0 - remarkably the third time in four years Bournemouth have won by that scoreline at Old Trafford - and Carrick looked destined to lose his job.

    It will be interesting how he deals with today's conference, in particular his relationship with skipper Bruno Fernandes and how he views his own job prospects.

  5. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 13:44 GMT

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    The scariest thing about Utd’s situation is I don’t know where we go from here if Carrick leaves. We’ve tried every type of manager. The only person that could steer this ship is Enrique, but he’d never come under the Glazers.

    Aidan

  6. Dressing rooms can be 'quite brutal places'published at 13:40 GMT

    Gary Neville
    Former Manchester United defender on Stick To Football

    We’ve all been in football dressing rooms, and they’re quite brutal places.

    When lads start speaking about managers... I didn’t have it with United, because we never had that level of discontent in the dressing room, but with England I did, particularly around Glenn Hoddle, when he turned on Becks, on Teddy, on a few other players.

    The toxicity, the sentiment in the dressing room, had gone.

    If Bruno Fernandes, the captain of the club, who to be fair has been a great performer for six years in terms of assists and goals, the one outstanding performer... if he comes out and questions the manager’s tactics after a 4-1 defeat in Como, where he’s played like a drain, and he’s been playing like a drain for three months, and the rest of them have as well, that is only 1 or 2% of what they’re actually saying internally.

  7. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 13:37 GMT

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    The worst part of this is true United fans have seen our decline and rot happen for years. The only United thing left if our fans and badge and memories. The whole club needs stripping back to fundamentals and have a fans voice start with playing the academy boys !

    Alec

  8. Carrick's six-minute epic falls flat - what this time?published at 13:33 GMT

    Chelsea v Manchester United (Sat, 12:30 GMT)

    Manchester United

    Media caption,

    Michael Carrick says the squad is 'not divided' at Manchester United.

    It was just six days ago that we were sat eagerly awaiting a Michael Carrick news conference.

    That one came following the 4-1 loss at Como in the Champions League; a result compounded by Bruno Fernandes' coming out and publicly criticising the team's tactics post-match.

    Carrick's response was to come out and deliver a near six-minute monologue in which he spoke about the club's history, the need for the hard work and humility that had brought previous success, before talking any questions.

    Well, the message fell rather flat as his side slumped to a 3-0 home loss to Bournemouth.

    So, what does Carrick do now?

    We'll find out what he's had to say at around 14:00 GMT.

  9. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 13:30 GMT

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    Clearly keeping Carrick in charge until they have the replacement ready. They'll want to avoid putting another interim in. Lets hope Omar and Wilcox soon get replaced too.

    RP

  10. Carrick needs the players 'more than they need him'published at 13:24 GMT

    Chelsea v Manchester United (Sat, 12:30 GMT)

    Roy Keane
    Former Manchester United captain on the Stick to Football podcast

    [Michael Carrick] is in trouble with that group of players isn’t he? He’s in trouble and the problem is he needs the players more than they need him. They got him the job last year, he got a two-year deal on the back of it.

    There's now obviously whatever’s happened in pre-season, energy levels, Bruno [Fernandes] is not performing, keepers making mistakes – all these basic things they were doing well last year and they had a bit of momentum, they cant get it this year.

    Don’t know what happened in pre-season, did they come back too early? Bruno has come back off the World Cup. Keeper made a big mistake at the World Cup. Have they lost a bit of confidence?

    Whatever all the stats about running, I know its not good. Look at the goals [so] far, they’ve won one game. Get beaten by Brighton in the Cup.

    It doesn’t look good but I am glad he has been given time and I don’t mean that in a nasty [way]. I would say that for most managers.

    If he is getting another opportunity but as soon as the lose another game, if they lose to Chelsea on Saturday, it will be the same conversation on Sunday.

    People are watching the TV looking for a manager, a man to lose his job. That’s what you’re waiting for.

  11. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 13:20 GMT

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    Please stop the managerial merry go round and stick with Michael. At some stage we have to realise constant change gets the club nowhere.

    Andrew

  12. Man Utd's upcoming fixturespublished at 13:15 GMT

    All times GMT

    Manchester United

    If Michael Carrick is to turn things around at Old Trafford, these are the fixtures within which he'll have to do it.

    The international break comes between the home game against Aston Villa and the always eagerly-anticipated trip to Anfield. Will Carrick still be in the dugout for that one?

    • 31 October, 12:30: v Chelsea (a)
    • 3 November, 20:00: v Roma (h), Champions League
    • 8 November, 16:30: v Aston Villa (h)
    • 22 November, 16:30: v Liverpool (a)
    • 25 November, 20:00: v Sporting (a), Champions League
    • 28 November, 15:00: v Brentford (h)
  13. 'Sometimes a manager needs sacking for their own good'published at 13:10 GMT

    Chelsea v Manchester United (Sat, 12:30 GMT)

    Michael CarrickImage source, Getty Images

    Former Manchester United defender Gary Neville and former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher have been speaking about Michael Carrick's future on the Stick to Football podcast, and believe that Carrick leaving the club would be best for his own sake.

    Neville said: "Sometimes a manager needs sacking for their own good. I needed sacking at Valencia. I was happy that they put me out of my misery."

    Carragher said: "I think he can never say publicly, but I think Michael Carrick would want to be put out of his misery. I really do.

    "The thought of going into that training ground now...and trying to do that team talk before Chelsea, when you know the players just aren’t having it at all.

    "Those players know Michael Carrick’s not going to be there in two or three weeks. He knows it, they know it, everybody knows it."

  14. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 13:07 GMT

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    What has Carrick done in his managerial career that gives United fans confidence he will turn it around? Take away the ex player factor & he shouldn’t be there.

    Mike

  15. Carrick and Fernandes hold clear-the-air talkspublished at 13:02 GMT

    Chelsea v Manchester United (Sat, 12:30 GMT)

    Manchester United

    Michael Carrick and Bruno FernandesImage source, Getty Images

    Another thread in all this is the ongoing Bruno Fernandes situation.

    Michael Carrick and Fernandes have held clear-the-air talks before the team's trip to Chelsea.

    Captain Fernandes, 32, was an unused substitute during United's 3-0 defeat by Bournemouth on Sunday.

    The Portuguese was dropped to the bench after he criticised Carrick's tactics following the 4-1 loss against Como in the Champions League.

    Sources have told BBC Sport that the pair spoke privately at the club's training ground on Tuesday, with the talks aimed at airing issues.

    It is unclear whether Fernandes, who was made club captain in 2023, apologised for his critical comments.

    Will we see Fernandes return to the starting line-up at Chelsea?

  16. Postpublished at 12:58 GMT

    This is the problem they've had for some time, Graham. But then plenty of of others would say the same.

    All clubs would like some stability but getting it - and then keeping it - is easier said than done.

    Admittedly, United have managed to make themselves more unstable than most in recent times.

  17. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 12:54 GMT

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    Define "turn this around". Because he could win a few games and then go back to this miserable form. That's instability. United are absolutely desperate for that and I don't think it'll be found with Carrick as boss.

    Graham

  18. Carrick to stay in charge of Man Utd for Chelsea gamepublished at 12:50 GMT

    Chelsea v Manchester United (Sat, 12:30 GMT)

    Manchester United

    Michael CarrickImage source, Getty Images

    This is the latest then...

    Michael Carrick will remain in charge of Manchester United for their trip to Chelsea this weekend.

    Sources have told BBC Sport that the 45-year-old will be given the opportunity to turn things around at Old Trafford following a dismal start to the campaign.

    Carrick oversaw training on Tuesday morning, as United look to end a run of eight matches without a win in all competitions when they visit Stamford Bridge on Saturday.

    Sunday's 3-0 defeat by Bournemouth at Old Trafford plunged Carrick's future into doubt, with United sitting one place above the relegation zone.

    It is understood United's hierarchy have explored the possibility of replacing Carrick, with ex-Newcastle United boss Eddie Howe and former Germany head coach Julian Nagelsmann under consideration.

    But sources have told BBC Sport that the former Middlesbrough manager will not only take charge against Chelsea but will also be given a chance to revive the club's fortunes on the pitch.

  19. Postpublished at 12:47 GMT

    Chelsea v Manchester United (Sat, 12:30 GMT)

    Manchester United

    Right then, back to Manchester United, Michael Carrick and this very strange situation we find ourselves in where everyone assumed he'd be sacked, most still expect he will be before too long and yet, for now, he's expected to carry on as if that isn't the case...

  20. Brighton team newspublished at 12:45 GMT

    Manchester City v Brighton (Sat, 15:00 GMT)

    Brighton & Hove Albion

    Brighton boss Fabian Hurzeler on his team news: "Chema Andres, Ferdi Kadioglu and Charalampos Kostoulas we rested yesterday and we are quite convinced they will be an options for Saturday, so this is new information we can give.

    "Regarding Pascal Struijk, he won't be an option for the weekend. We are convinced he will be back afterwards.

    "Regarding the other players who have been out for a long time, Zadok Yohanna is back on the training pitch, also Stefanos Tzimas after his ACL so plenty of positives."

    For more from Fabian Hurzeler's news conference, click here.