
How not to make an argument
Radio 4’s daily prayer and reflection, with Rabbi Monique Mayer, spiritual leader of Bristol and West Progressive Jewish Congregation.
Good Morning.
Recently, after giving feedback, I was told 'you’re extremely judgemental'. And I said, 'yes, that’s probably true; all of us are at least a little judgemental'. Over the years I’ve worked hard to become less so because I know that the key to developing positive relationships requires awareness and sensitivity to how I interact with other human beings.
All around us are issues causing rifts between families, neighbours, and friends. Recently I heard two callers on a phone-in discussion shouting over each other. There was no civility, no consideration, just shouting. Questions felt like accusations—judgemental, not curious. I thought, how terribly sad. How can we hope to live alongside each other if we can’t even take the time to listen?
The Sages taught:
'Who is wise? One who learns from every human being, as it is said in Psalms "From all my teachers I grow wise"'.
I love this quote because it reminds me that every person has something to teach me. Every single person. They might teach me how to make a better argument—or how NOT to make an argument. They might teach me how to ask better questions. And, sometimes, they might even teach me a thing or two about myself.
May we all learn to enter each conversation from a place of curiosity and compassion, and may we come away having been enriched by the encounter with another human being.
