bbc.co.uk Navigation

Victims and pawns of the war

  • Nick
  • 1 Feb 06, 08:00 PM

The photo of Tony Blair meeting the man who would become the 100th soldier to die in the Iraq war adds personal poignancy to a grim milestone. Of course, it changes nothing. Not the tragedy for his family and friends. Not the tragedy for all those who lost someone who happens not to have been the 100th and happens not to have met the prime minister. Not the question of whether war was right or wrong.

But inevitably those opposed to the war or critical of Tony Blair will use it against him. Some are demanding to know how he deals with the victims of "his war" or are asking why his letters are typed and not hand written, or why he doesn't attend funerals or meet the bereaved families. Number 10 is reluctant to be drawn on any of this knowing all too well the dangers of being seen to parade the prime minister's emotions publicly.

I'm told that he does write to all. I understand that there is a policy of not phoning families or going to meet coffins or attend funerals since some families would not want it and inevitably if it was done for one some would argue it should be done for all. It's all just a reminder that the victims of this war also become pawns in the political battle about whether it should have been fought at all.

A slow decay

  • Nick
  • 1 Feb 06, 11:51 AM

"These things happen". Thus Number 10 has decided to shrug off defeat last night. I suspect that at Prime Minister's Questions Tony Blair wll try to laugh off the fact that his absence made the difference between defeat and victory.

George Galloway turned out to be a more reliable supporter of a Labour manifesto pledge than the PM himself. Despite their obvious distractions, Mark Oaten and Charles Kennedy turned out to be more consistent voters.

Now, it's true the world will go on. It's true too that last night's defeat will act as a shot across the bows before the votes that really matter on schools reform. But - and it's a big but - governments with a majority this size should not lose votes, not least on manifesto pledges. It suggests not so much a loss of authority as a lack of grip by Team Blair.

It also demonstrates the slow decay of instinctive discipline and loyalty in the Parliamentary Labour Party. Those things do happen to governments, but usually only just before their leaders stand aside or are pushed.

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

BBC.co.uk