BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

28 October 2014
BerkshireBerkshire

BBC Homepage
England
»BBC Local
Berkshire
Things to do
People & Places
Nature
History
Religion & Ethics
Arts and Culture
BBC Introducing
TV & Radio

Sites near Berkshire

Hampshire
London
Oxford
Wiltshire

Related BBC Sites

England

Contact Us

People

Kelly & Gavin at Brandon's grave, with son Connor
The Swains at Brandon's grave

No toys on grave, church tells parents

A Hungerford couple have told how they arrived at their son's grave to find a letter from church authorities, insisting that they remove toys left at the plot or risk them being taken away.

Watch a video report:
videoBBC South Today's Ben Moore reports >
Audio and Video links on this page require Realplayer

19-year-old Kelly Swain lost son Brandon to a miscarriage four years ago, when she was six months pregnant.

Kelly and dad Gavin, 24, found a note next to Brandon's grave while visiting the £70 plot, at Christchurch graveyard in Kintbury, on Christmas Eve.

The note, from the church council, told the couple to remove toys from the grave by the end of February or risk them being removed.

The church said it was necessary to remove the toys in order to ensure grass near the plot could be cut.

Gavin Swain
Gavin Swain: 'Why can't we have it how we want?'

"Christmas drained away," says Kelly. "This is how we've made the grave and we'd like it to stay that way. It brought all the heartache back again."

"We've paid for the plot," adds Gavin, "so why can't we have it how we want?"

'Holding the balance'

The church says it had been approached by other families with nearby plots who "wanted to deal with their bereavement in an environment they felt appropriate".

The Revd Norman Russell, Archdeacon of Berkshire, says ecclesiastical authorities will always be treading a fine line in these matters.

"If it becomes impossible to maintain the churchyard it affects other grieving families as well," he told the BBC.

Revd Norman Russell
Revd Norman Russell: 'It affects other families'

"The real difficulty for the church is holding the balance between the interests of one genuinely bereaved family and other families with graves in the area."

Churchyard regulations allow objects to be left on a grave for one year before they must be removed.

But the Swains remain upset that the warden resorted to leaving a note on Brandon's grave, even though the church insists it tried other methods of contact first.

last updated: 05/01/07
Have Your Say
Your name:
Your comment:
The BBC reserves the right to edit comments submitted.

Ruth
I can totally relate to this couple. I have been through the same thing. My husband and 7 year old son were killed in a car crash 5 years ago. I put flowers, a few toys and windmills at the grave and I also was told, by a letter, to remove them, or they would remove them for me. I stood my ground and they were indeed removed by the Parish Council.I do not agree with the comment about it being 'unhealthy' to want to do this so long after the death. I have moved on and started a new life and can openly say I am very happy.Of course I think of the 2 people I lost everyday, but not in a morbid way. I have seen many graves where there are toys, candles, windmills, crystals, etc and it makes the churchyard a wonderful personal place to visit.People like myself, kelly and Gavin should stand upto the decisions made by the hierachy. Set standards for others that come after us.

Helen
I agree with Jo and the Church. If nothing else it can't be healthy for the couple to behave like this, clinging on to a lost baby. It must be a terrible thing to go through, but it is ridiculous to allow people to offend and distress others who have also lost family. From the picture it doesn't seem as though we are talking about just one toy... Everybody has rights and often those who go banging on about theirs and how difficult things are for them, often don't realise they are trampling all over other people's feelings who have the same rights that they do. We must learn to share and respect one another - this includes the times when things are difficult.

Jackie
Having recently lost a baby myself I know how important it is to the parents to be able to have their baby's grave just as they want it. It is one of the only things that they ever able to do for their children and to have someone tell them it is inappropriate to do so is ludicros and extremely insensitive. How is it inappropriate that a baby's grave has toy's on it, I just don't understand! Kelly and Gavin should have the right to deal with their loss in whatever way they feel appropriate. How would these people who find it distressing to see toys on a grave feel if it was their baby or child who had died.

Patricia Bird
I cannot believe how ridiculous, small, stingy, insensitive and selfish some people in this country can be. How cruel of the Church Council. I cannot understand how the toys affect the bereavement of other families and how they can make the environment "inappropriate".As per "cutting the grass", can't the toys be moved aside and then placed back after the grass has been cut? Loosing one you love is not easy, and it's even worse when it's a baby that you never had the chance to cuddle or kiss.

will - 21
bloody ridicoulous if i got a note on dads memorial saying this i would rip it up and put more stuff there terrible

Amy
Having read this story I am appalled that the warden left a note on the grave. This is possibly the most cold and insensitive thing that someone could do to a family which has lost a child, and I find it VERY hard to believe that the church couldn't have contacted the family in a more appropriate manner. As for the issue regarding the toys, it certainly would not bother me if I were visiting a relative in a neighbouring grave - and nor should it!

Jo
I agree with the Church. surely theparents could have their own personal place in their own home. I have family who are buried at this cemetary and I for one do not feel like walking into Toys R Us when I go to remember my family. Have heart, Kelly & Gavin.

SEE ALSO
home
HOME
email
EMAIL
print
PRINT
Go to the top of the page
TOP
SITE CONTENTS
SEE ALSO

Colin Evans's gardening tips
Weekly tips from BBC Berkshire's gardening guru.

The Session
The new music radio show




About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy